This brought a smile to my morning.
Marines aren't trained to be wise defenders. At least they weren't while I was in. And the thought of saying such a thing to the people who trained me makes me laugh. I can just see the explosion of contempt. Truly laughable. Not mocking you, just imagining the shade of red and the stream of profanities that would be heard for blocks in every direction if someone had said something like that to the gentlemen who trained me.
While I did not serve during wartime I was prepared to go - all Marines are, should be. Surviving combat isn't about being a wise defender. It's about being an emotionless killing machine. It's about doing everything humanly possible to ensure you live and the other guy dies. Everything - not just the nice things or socially acceptable things. Everything.
One of my favorite Marine stories from the first Gulf War was about the Marines who decided to attack a group of entrenched Iraqis with bulldozers instead of weapons. The Marines simply used the bulldozers to bury the Iraqis. Alive. Easier to bury them than try to fight them. There was briefly talk of charging the Marines with war crimes. War is winning at all costs. Kill or be killed. You need to be more willing to kill than your enemy is. Indeed we do demand cruel killers. And that's as it should be. War isn't for the faint of heart or weak of will. It demands you be able to kill up close, staring at the person you're killing in the face. It demands you continue to fight while you watch your comrades die around you. If you can't do those things you will die.
War is not some sterile academic exercise. And regardless of fitting the textbook definition of PTSD or not I am sure war changes people. War requires people turn into killers. To paraphrase what someone said earlier they have to "turn it on". This guy I am sure has seen his friends injured and killed. I would be willing to bet he's killed people. His is switched on. And you're demanding that he conform to other behavioral norms (treat puppies with love and respect). I submit he is behaving within the norms of the environment he is in - and we put him there.
You are right on one point; judgment does play a large role - and this guy obviously lacked judgment. Lacking judgment is something that should be punished by an article 15. It reminds of the guys who burned a bunch of bodies in Afghanistan. That also was a dumb move. But nobody was screaming for dishonorable discharges in that case.












